Bay Colony Fort Lauderdale: Gated Waterfront Homes (2026)
October 12, 2026
Insights from Josh & Karla Ziegelbaum – Ziegelbaum Group at Compass
Bay Colony is a guard-gated, single-family, deep-water community in East Fort Lauderdale, Florida, located off Bayview Drive in the 33308 ZIP code, east of Federal Highway and west of the Intracoastal Waterway. Its homes sit on canals with private dockage and direct access to the Intracoastal and the ocean.
This guide covers that single-family gated community — not the Bay Colony Club condominium that shares its name. It is also one of the most consistently misreported neighborhoods in Broward County. Almost every major listing site publishes Bay Colony data that is wrong — the amenities, the price range, the schools, and in some cases which direction Federal Highway runs. This guide gives you the verified picture, and shows you exactly where the public data breaks.
Where Is Bay Colony Located?
Bay Colony sits in East Fort Lauderdale, in the 33308 ZIP code. The Intracoastal Waterway forms its eastern edge. Federal Highway (US-1) runs to the west — a detail several published descriptions get backwards. Commercial Boulevard is to the north, Oakland Park Boulevard to the south.
Entry is from Bayview Drive through a single guarded gate. The street names inside are Bay Colony Drive, Bay Colony Lane, North and South Compass Drive, and Compass Lane.
The Landings is immediately adjacent. Coral Ridge lies south, and Imperial Point sits across Federal Highway to the west. Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport is roughly ten miles south.
Bay Colony Fort Lauderdale: Neighborhood Facts
- City: Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida
- ZIP code: 33308
- Property type: Single-family homes only
- Access: Guard-gated, single controlled point of entry off Bayview Drive
- Streets: Bay Colony Drive, Bay Colony Lane, North and South Compass Drive, Compass Lane
- Water: Canal frontage with private dockage, Intracoastal and ocean access
- Size: Small — the figure most often published is 108 homes, which we have not confirmed against the plat
- Origin: Platted in the early 1960s as the Third Section of The Landings; built out through the late 1960s and early 1970s
- Association: Bay Colony Protective Association, Inc. — Florida document number 716838, filed July 1, 1969, status ACTIVE, registered address 1 North Compass Drive, Guard House
- Not the same as: Bay Colony Club, a separate condominium community on Bay Club Drive (Florida document number 717251)
- Nearest hospitals: Holy Cross Health and Broward Health Imperial Point, both on North Federal Highway
Looking in Bay Colony? Some owners sell quietly, before a home is ever listed. Call us and we’ll tell you what’s coming up.
Is Bay Colony Gated?
Yes. Bay Colony is one of the few genuinely guard-gated single-family communities in East Fort Lauderdale. Entry is controlled at a staffed guard house, and the association’s registered principal address on file with the State of Florida is 1 North Compass Drive, Guard House.
You will see Bay Colony described online as having 24/7 guard security. Treat that as a question, not a fact. Staffed hours, overnight coverage, and whether water access is separately controlled are not published in any source we can verify. Get them in writing before your inspection period closes. A guard house that exists and a guard house staffed around the clock are two different purchases.
What the Listing Sites Get Wrong About Bay Colony
This is the section no other Bay Colony page will give you, and it is worth more than anything else here. Five specific errors circulate on the major portals. Each one costs somebody money.
1. The amenity list belongs to a different community
Search Bay Colony and you will find pages listing a clubhouse, pool, spa, sauna, fitness center, billiards room, tennis and pickleball courts, racquetball, shuffleboard, a restaurant, a library and a business center. Those are the amenities of Bay Colony Club, the condominium community on Bay Club Drive. The single-family gated enclave is a residential street network behind a guard house. Buyers have toured here expecting a clubhouse they would never have access to.
2. The price range blends two property types
Published Bay Colony price ranges often start in the $200,000s. Those are condominium units at Bay Colony Club. A single-family deep-water home in gated Bay Colony does not trade anywhere near that number. A range spanning from the $200Ks to eight figures describes two different markets stacked on top of each other — and it is useless for pricing either one.
3. The per-square-foot and days-on-market averages are contaminated
The same blending runs through the statistics. When a site reports an average price per square foot, a list-to-sell ratio or an average days on market for “Bay Colony,” check whether condominium sales are inside that calculation. They usually are. The resulting number describes no actual property, and it is the number sellers get anchored to.
4. The school assignments do not match the location
Several portals publish Pompano Beach-area school assignments for Bay Colony. Bay Colony is in Fort Lauderdale, in 33308, south of Commercial Boulevard. Broward County Public Schools assigns by address, redraws boundaries periodically, and operates choice and magnet programs on top of that. Verify assignment for the specific property with the district directly — do not take it from a listing page.
5. Some pages get the geography backwards
You will find descriptions placing Federal Highway to the east of Bay Colony. The Intracoastal Waterway is to the east. Federal Highway is west. If a page cannot place the neighborhood correctly on a map, treat the rest of its data accordingly.
None of this is an argument that the portals are useless. It is an argument that in a community this small, with this much name collision, you verify at the source. We tell you where every source is further down.
Thinking of selling in Bay Colony? We’ll give you a free home value within 24 hours, based on your dock, frontage and the homes that actually sold inside the gate, not a website estimate.
Or call (954) 540-9119.
What Makes Bay Colony Different From Other Fort Lauderdale Neighborhoods?
Three things: the gate, the water, and the scale. Most deep-water streets in East Fort Lauderdale are open neighborhoods. Bay Colony is closed, with one way in. And it is small enough that turnover is low and most of what trades here never generates the public attention a larger neighborhood would.
Then there is the history, which almost nobody writes about. Bay Colony, The Landings and Imperial Point were developed by the same firm — Haft-Gaines, the operation of Burt S. Haft and Jack W. Gaines working through Monarch Realty, which was planning this stretch of Broward from 1960. Imperial Point opened that October with roughly 1,470 homes west of Federal Highway. The Landings followed in spring 1962, with models near NE 55th Street and Bayview Drive advertised from the high thirty thousands — private dock included.
Bay Colony was originally platted as The Landings’ Third Section, then developed and marketed separately with its own association, incorporated in 1969. That shared origin explains the lot geometry, canal widths and dock orientations that feel so familiar when you walk from one into the other. You are walking two chapters of one plan.
Bay Colony vs. Bay Colony Club: Which One Are You Looking At?
The single most important distinction for anyone searching this neighborhood.
- Bay Colony — single-family, guard-gated, deep-water. Streets: Bay Colony Drive, Bay Colony Lane, Compass Drive, Compass Lane. Association: Bay Colony Protective Association, Inc., Florida document number 716838.
- Bay Colony Club — a condominium community on Bay Club Drive, with its own board, budget, assessments and amenity package. Florida document number 717251.
Two communities. Two corporate registrations. Two property types. Two price bands. Some sites do separate them properly; many do not. Before you draw any conclusion from a “Bay Colony” market report, check which one it describes.
Bay Colony Home Values in 2026
Bay Colony sits at the upper end of East Fort Lauderdale pricing. Three things drive value here more than square footage does:
- Dockage and water frontage. Linear feet at the seawall and the size of vessel the property can actually accommodate. Published descriptions cite dockage up to roughly 100 feet; it varies by lot and should be measured, not assumed.
- Bridge clearance to the ocean. The controlling clearance on the route out is often the difference between two otherwise identical homes.
- Condition and era of the renovation. Much of the original stock has been rebuilt or substantially renovated. What was done, when, and under what permits matters more than the original year built.
Automated estimates are unreliable here for two compounding reasons: the community is small and sales are infrequent, so models have few comparable transactions to work from; and the name collision described above pulls condominium sales into the same bucket. We go through how luxury value is actually built on the east side in what makes one Fort Lauderdale luxury home worth more than another.
Waterfront, Docks and Ocean Access
In a deep-water community the dock is often worth more than the kitchen. Four things to pin down on any Bay Colony property:
- The route out, and its controlling bridge clearance. “Ocean access” is not one thing. Ask for the specific route to the Intracoastal and out, and the lowest fixed bridge along it. We break the distinction down in fixed bridges vs. no fixed bridges.
- Seawall and dock condition and permit history. A seawall is a six-figure item. Have it inspected by a marine structures specialist, not a general home inspector. Age of the cap, condition of the tiebacks and any spalling are what matter.
- Measured depth at low tide. Not “deep water” — an actual sounding at the dock, for the draft of the boat you intend to keep.
- A real flood insurance quote, early. Since FEMA moved to Risk Rating 2.0, your premium is driven by your own structure’s elevation, distance to water, replacement cost and foundation type rather than by the zone letter on the map. See how the flood zones actually work here.
The Bay Colony Lifestyle
Dining
Minutes from the Oakland Park Boulevard and Federal Highway corridors, and a short drive from Las Olas Boulevard, which carries most of the city’s higher-end dining. Lauderdale-by-the-Sea’s walkable restaurant village is a few minutes north along the beach.
Shopping
The Galleria at Fort Lauderdale on East Sunrise Boulevard is the closest full retail center, with everyday shopping along Federal Highway and Commercial Boulevard.
The Beach and Water
Fort Lauderdale Beach is a few minutes east, with Hugh Taylor Birch State Park south along A1A. For residents here, though, the water access that matters is the one behind the house — a private dock with a run straight out to the Intracoastal.
Community
Small, quiet and private by design. The gate keeps through-traffic out entirely, which is the practical reason most buyers choose Bay Colony over an open waterfront street nearby.
Healthcare
Holy Cross Health and Broward Health Imperial Point are both on North Federal Highway, within a short drive.
Private Schools Near Bay Colony
One of the quiet advantages of this stretch of East Fort Lauderdale is how short the school run is. Several of South Florida’s best-known independent and parochial schools sit within a few minutes of the gate — a real factor for the relocation buyers who make up much of the demand here.
Pine Crest School
1501 NE 62nd Street, Fort Lauderdale — essentially straight across Federal Highway from Bay Colony, and the closest major independent school to the neighborhood. Pine Crest serves Pre-Kindergarten through Grade 12, was founded in 1934, and is accredited by Cognia, the Florida Council of Independent Schools and the Southern Association of Independent Schools. Enrollment across its two campuses is listed at 2,694 students for 2026–27.
Westminster Academy
5601 North Federal Highway, Fort Lauderdale — a few blocks south of the Pine Crest campus and an easy run from the gate. Westminster is a Christian school serving PK2 through Grade 12, founded in 1971 as an educational ministry of Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church, and accredited by the Middle States Association of Colleges and Schools, Christian Schools of Florida and the National Council for Private School Accreditation.
Cardinal Gibbons High School
2900 NE 47th Street, Fort Lauderdale — a Roman Catholic college preparatory high school within the Archdiocese of Miami, which opened in 1961. It sits south of Bay Colony on the east side of Federal Highway, inside the same 33308 ZIP code.
St. Mark’s Episcopal School
1750 East Oakland Park Boulevard, Fort Lauderdale — a co-ed Episcopal day school serving preschool through Grade 8, listed by the Episcopal Church in Southeast Florida and a member of the National Association of Episcopal Schools. The closest option for families who want a small lower- and middle-school environment before a 9–12 program.
For public school assignment, see the correction above: verify with Broward County Public Schools directly rather than relying on a listing page.
Is Bay Colony a Good Investment in 2026?
The case for Bay Colony is scarcity. Guard-gated single-family deep-water inventory in East Fort Lauderdale is effectively fixed — nobody is building another one. Demand for controlled access has gone up, not down, and these lots are not reproducible.
The case against treating it casually is carrying cost. Insurance, seawall and dock capital expense, and association obligations are real numbers that belong in your analysis before you make an offer, not after. That is true of any waterfront purchase in this market, and more so in a small community where the public data is thin and partly wrong.
Weighing Bay Colony against the two neighborhoods beside it? Our side-by-side: Coral Ridge vs. Bay Colony vs. The Landings.
Buying in Bay Colony: What to Know Before You Search
Three questions, in writing, before your inspection period expires:
- Is association membership mandatory or voluntary, and is the assessment a lien-able obligation? Completely different financial pictures. Get the answer from the governing documents, not from recollection.
- What is the current assessment, what does it cover, and what is the reserve position? Ask for the current budget and the most recent financial statement. Where a gate, guard house and private roads are involved, ask who is responsible for capital repair of each.
- What does the guard house actually cover? Staffed hours, overnight coverage, and whether water access is separately controlled.
Florida law entitles a purchaser to association documents in most circumstances, and your contract should give you the window to review them. If they are slow to arrive, that is information too.
Selling in Bay Colony: What to Know in 2026
The pricing work here is comparable selection, and it is the whole job. With few sales inside the community, the right comparable set reaches into adjacent deep-water streets in The Landings and Lauderdale Harbours — screened property by property for dockage, frontage and bridge clearance, then adjusted for the gate.
What we will not do is price your home off an automated estimate or a blended neighborhood figure. In a community this small, with a condominium sharing its name, that number is noise — and starting from it costs real money.
Frequently Asked Questions: Bay Colony Fort Lauderdale
Where is Bay Colony in Fort Lauderdale?
Bay Colony is in East Fort Lauderdale in the 33308 ZIP code, off Bayview Drive, with the Intracoastal Waterway on its eastern edge and Federal Highway to the west. Commercial Boulevard is to the north and Oakland Park Boulevard to the south. Some published descriptions place Federal Highway east of the community, which is incorrect.
Is Bay Colony Fort Lauderdale gated?
Yes. Bay Colony is a guard-gated single-family community with a single controlled point of entry off Bayview Drive. The Bay Colony Protective Association’s registered principal address on file with the State of Florida is 1 North Compass Drive, Guard House. Staffed hours and overnight coverage are not published in any verifiable source, so confirm them in writing during your inspection period rather than assuming around-the-clock staffing.
Is Bay Colony the same as Bay Colony Club?
No. Bay Colony is the single-family guard-gated community off Bayview Drive, and its association, Bay Colony Protective Association, Inc., is Florida document number 716838, filed July 1, 1969. Bay Colony Club is a separate condominium community on Bay Club Drive with its own registration, document number 717251, its own board and its own amenities. They are different property types in different price bands.
Does Bay Colony have a clubhouse, pool and tennis courts?
No. Those amenities belong to Bay Colony Club, the neighboring condominium community. The single-family gated Bay Colony is a residential street network behind a guard house, without a community clubhouse, pool, fitness center or courts. Listing sites frequently attach the condominium’s amenity list to the single-family community, which misleads buyers touring the neighborhood. If amenities are what you are after, you are looking at Bay Colony Club, not Bay Colony.
What ZIP code is Bay Colony in?
Bay Colony is in 33308, in East Fort Lauderdale, Broward County, Florida.
How many homes are in Bay Colony?
Bay Colony is a small single-family community of a few streets off Bayview Drive. The figure most often published is 108 homes, but we have not confirmed it against the recorded plat and do not publish counts we cannot source. Exact parcel counts are verifiable by plat at the Broward County Property Appraiser. Bay Colony Club, the neighboring condominium community, is counted separately.
Do Bay Colony homes have docks?
Most do. Bay Colony is a deep-water community built on canals with private dockage, which is the main reason buyers choose it. Published descriptions cite dock lengths up to roughly 100 feet, but dock size, seawall condition and the controlling bridge clearance on the route to the ocean vary by property and should be measured and verified individually rather than assumed.
Are there any homes for sale in Bay Colony right now?
Inventory is limited. This is a small community with low turnover, and in a given month there may be only a handful of single-family homes listed — sometimes none. Searching “Bay Colony” on a portal will usually return condominium units at Bay Colony Club mixed in with, or instead of, single-family homes. For an accurate current list of single-family homes available inside the gated community, including properties not yet publicly marketed, contact us directly.
How do I find off-market homes in Bay Colony?
In a community this small, a meaningful share of activity never reaches the public portals. Owners here tend to value privacy and often prefer a quiet sale over a marketed one. The practical route is to work with an agent who already covers these streets and will approach owners directly on your behalf. We work Bay Colony, The Landings and the surrounding deep-water streets every week, and we will make those approaches for you rather than waiting for something to be listed.
What size boat can I keep at a Bay Colony home?
It depends on three things, and all three are property-specific: linear dock footage at the seawall, measured water depth at the dock at low tide, and the controlling bridge clearance on the route from the property to the Intracoastal and out. Published descriptions cite dockage up to roughly 100 feet, but it varies lot to lot. If you are buying for a particular vessel, get a measured sounding and confirm the clearance on the actual route before you go under contract — do not rely on the words “ocean access” in a listing.
Can I tear down and build new in Bay Colony?
Several homes in the community have been rebuilt or substantially renovated. Any new construction is subject to City of Fort Lauderdale permitting and zoning, and may also be subject to the association’s governing documents. Confirm setbacks, height limits and lot coverage with the City, and ask the association whether any architectural review applies, before you price a teardown. On a deep-water lot the seawall and dock condition belong in that budget too.
How do I get through the gate to see a Bay Colony home?
You cannot drive in and tour the neighborhood on your own. Entry is controlled at the guard house, and showings are arranged in advance through the listing agent with your agent and the appointment on record. If you want to see what is available inside the gate, the appointment has to come first — which is the main practical reason buyers here work with an agent who already covers the community.
Do I need a cash offer to compete in Bay Colony?
Not necessarily, but financing terms carry more weight here than in a broader market. With so few comparable sales inside the community, an appraiser has a thin set to work from, and that appraisal risk is what sellers are really weighing when they compare offers. Discuss proof of funds and appraisal-gap language with your agent before you write, so a financed offer competes on certainty rather than losing on it.
How much are Bay Colony HOA dues?
We do not publish a figure we cannot source. A number under $700 a month circulates online, but it cannot be verified, and it is not clear whether it describes the single-family association’s assessment or the condominium’s — which is precisely the problem. Request the governing documents, the current budget and the most recent financial statement during your inspection period, and ask specifically whether the assessment is a lien-able obligation.
Why are online home value estimates for Bay Colony wrong?
Two compounding reasons. The community is small and sales are infrequent, so automated models have very few comparable transactions to work from. And the Bay Colony name attaches to both a single-family community and a separate condominium community, so price ranges, per-square-foot figures and days-on-market averages that mix the two describe no actual property. Comparables for a single-family waterfront home should be drawn from screened single-family waterfront sales with similar dockage, frontage and bridge clearance.
What is my Bay Colony home worth?
Not what an automated estimate says. Those models have very few comparable sales inside this community to work from, and the shared name pulls condominium transactions into the calculation. A real valuation here is built from screened single-family waterfront sales, matched on dock length, lot frontage, bridge clearance and the quality and date of the renovation, then adjusted for the gate. That is the work, and it is the difference between a number and a price.
Should I sell my Bay Colony home off-market?
It is worth considering here more than in most neighborhoods. Owners in a small gated community often value privacy and controlled access to the property, and an off-market sale delivers both. The trade-off is reach: a quiet sale limits the buyer pool, which can cost you money if the house would have drawn competition. The right answer depends on your price point, your timeline and how unusual the property is — it is a decision worth modelling both ways before you commit.
Does the guard gate help or hurt my resale value?
It generally works in your favor, because controlled access is the primary reason buyers choose Bay Colony over an open waterfront street nearby. The practical caveat is cost: a gate, guard house and private roads are capital items that somebody funds. A well-advised buyer will ask about the assessment, what it covers and the reserve position, so have the governing documents, the current budget and the most recent financial statement ready before you go to market.
Who is buying in Bay Colony right now?
At this price point in East Fort Lauderdale, demand comes mostly from relocation buyers out of the Northeast and internationally, and from South Florida owners trading up into deep water with controlled access. These are buyers who want a dock and a gate in the same purchase, which narrows their options to a very short list of communities — and Bay Colony is on it.
I am looking at a condo on Bay Club Drive. Is that Bay Colony?
No. Bay Club Drive is Bay Colony Club, a separate condominium community with its own association, its own assessments and its own amenities. Our Bay Colony practice is the gated single-family community off Bayview Drive, so we are likely not the right fit for a Bay Colony Club purchase. If you are looking at single-family waterfront anywhere in East Fort Lauderdale — Bay Colony, The Landings, Lauderdale Harbours or Coral Ridge — that is exactly what we do.
What schools serve Bay Colony?
Broward County Public Schools assigns by address rather than by neighborhood and redraws boundaries periodically. Several listing sites publish Pompano Beach-area assignments for Bay Colony, which does not match its Fort Lauderdale 33308 location, so verify assignment for the specific property with the district directly. Nearby private options include Pine Crest School on NE 62nd Street, Westminster Academy on North Federal Highway, Cardinal Gibbons High School on NE 47th Street, and St. Mark’s Episcopal School on East Oakland Park Boulevard.
When was Bay Colony built?
Bay Colony was platted in the early 1960s as the Third Section of The Landings and built out through the late 1960s and early 1970s. Its association, Bay Colony Protective Association, Inc., was incorporated on July 1, 1969. Much of the original housing stock has since been substantially renovated or rebuilt.
Who developed Bay Colony and The Landings?
Both were developed by Haft-Gaines, the operation of Burt S. Haft and Jack W. Gaines working through Monarch Realty, which was planning this part of Broward County from 1960. The Landings’ models opened in spring 1962 near NE 55th Street and Bayview Drive, advertised from the high thirty thousands with a private dock included. The same firm developed Imperial Point, which opened in October 1960 with roughly 1,470 homes.
Was Bay Colony originally part of The Landings?
Yes. Bay Colony was originally platted as the Third Section of The Landings, then developed and marketed as its own community with its own association. The shared origin explains the similar lot geometry, canal widths and original construction era across the two neighborhoods.
How does Bay Colony compare to The Landings?
Same original developer and the same underlying plat, different governance and access. Bay Colony is gated with a guard house, and prices reflect the controlled access. The Landings has no gate, a voluntary residential association, broader inventory and a wider price range. Buyers who need controlled access choose Bay Colony; buyers who want more inventory usually look at The Landings first.
Does the flood zone determine my insurance cost in Bay Colony?
No. Since FEMA adopted Risk Rating 2.0, a National Flood Insurance Program premium is driven primarily by the individual building’s elevation, distance to water, replacement cost and foundation type rather than by the flood zone designation on the map. The zone still governs whether a federally backed lender requires you to carry flood insurance.
How far is Bay Colony from the airport and the beach?
Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport is roughly ten miles south of Bay Colony. Fort Lauderdale Beach is a few minutes east, and Lauderdale-by-the-Sea is a few minutes north along the coast.
Talk to Josh and Karla Before You Price or Offer in Bay Colony
This is a small community where the public data is actively wrong in specific, documentable ways, and where the governing documents are not online. That is exactly where having someone who has already done the records work saves you money rather than just saving you time.
We are Josh and Karla Ziegelbaum, co-founders of The Ziegelbaum Group at Compass. We live in Imperial Point, we work the east side every week, and we pull the plat, the corporate registration and the permit history ourselves rather than repeating what an aggregator says. If you are selling here, we will build your pricing from screened single-family waterfront comparables. If you are buying, we will get you the governing documents and the real insurance number before your inspection period closes.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Association documents, assessments, permitting requirements, school boundaries and flood insurance rates change. Confirm anything you intend to rely on with the association, Broward County, FEMA and your own advisors.
Further Reading
- Coral Ridge vs. Bay Colony vs. The Landings: Where Should You Buy?
- What Makes One Fort Lauderdale Luxury Home Worth More Than Another?
- Fixed Bridges vs. No Fixed Bridges on Fort Lauderdale Waterfront
- What Is My Imperial Point Home Worth in Today’s Market?
Get a Real Bay Colony ValuationSee Bay Colony Homes First
Resources: Florida Division of Corporations · Broward County Property Appraiser · Broward County Public Schools · FEMA Flood Map Service Center
The Ziegelbaum Group at Compass
Karla and Josh Ziegelbaum
+1 (954) 540-9119
info@ziegelbaumgroup.com
ziegelbaumgroup.com
1200 E Las Olas Blvd, Ste 103, 201 & 202, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
A Modern Approach to Luxury Real Estate
